All comparisonsAI ad creative

AdCreative.ai vs Pencil (2026): credits per brand or capped generations?

Credits counted per download, or capped generations from $14 a month.

Published by Adwize, which makes an AI agent for Meta ads. We are not affiliated with AdCreative.ai or Pencil. Prices read on their official pages on November 17, 2026.

The short answer

Choose AdCreative.ai if you want many creative formats and a score before launch: it makes ad visuals, copy and videos, runs AI product and fashion shoots, and its Creative Scoring AI predicts how a creative will perform. Its Starter plan costs $39 a month for 20 credits and one brand, a credit is used when you download a creative, and a 7-day trial with 20 credits is offered. On November 17, 2026, a Black Friday banner took 50% off quarterly and yearly plans, which put Starter at $20 a month billed yearly. Choose Pencil if you want a low entry price and launches from the same tool: Core costs $14 a month, or $11 billed yearly, for 50 generations, and Pencil launches and tracks ads on Meta, TikTok, YouTube, Google, DV360 and LinkedIn. Its monthly quotas are hard caps with no rollover. Every figure here was read on the official pages on November 17, 2026.

How do AdCreative.ai and Pencil compare?

How do AdCreative.ai and Pencil compare?
CriterionAdCreative.aiPencil
Category

AI ad creative

AI ad creative

Entry price, billed monthly

$39/mo (Starter, 20 credits, 1 brand)

$14/mo (Core, 50 generations)

Entry price, billed yearly

$20/mo billed yearly, during a Black Friday promotion

$11/mo billed yearly (Core)

Free plan or trial

7-day trial with 20 credits; no free plan

Six free guided ads at sign-up; no free plan

Pricing model

Credits per month and number of brands; discount by commitment

Generations (now called credits) per month; Pro on quote

Key features
  • Ad visuals, copy and videos (including UGC), also from a site URL
  • AI product and fashion shoots, in photo and video
  • Creative Scoring AI: predicts a creative’s performance before launch
  • Creative Insights: ad fatigue and category comparison for connected accounts
  • Competitor Insights and a brand and ad policy Compliance Checker
  • AI agents for copy, images, video and ads, plus your own workflows
  • Predictive creative scores and real-time insights
  • Launch and track ads on Meta, TikTok, YouTube, Google, DV360, LinkedIn
  • AI Auto Resize: one generation per format
  • Models from several providers, SOC 2 Type II, no training on client data
Integrations

Meta Ads, Google Ads, LinkedIn Ads, Pinterest Ads, Microsoft Ads, iStock (Getty Images) library, AdCreative mobile app, Asset management API (Enterprise)

Meta (Facebook and Instagram Ads), TikTok Ads, LinkedIn Ads, Google Ads, YouTube, DV360, Campaign Manager 360, Bynder and Orange Logic (DAM)

Rating shown by the vendor

No G2 or Capterra rating shown on its site

No G2 or Capterra rating shown on its site

What to know about AdCreative.ai’s prices

  • There is no /pricing page (it returned a 404): the price grid sits on the homepage.
  • A Black Friday banner on November 17, 2026 offered 50% off quarterly and yearly plans plus double credits, so the quarterly and yearly prices shown were promotional.
  • Credit rollover is contradictory: the pricing tooltip says credits carry over while the subscription is active, the terms (art. 4.6) exclude it.
  • The mobile version of the page shows other brand and user limits for some plans, and $599 in the Ultimate card text, against $999 on desktop.
  • Whether the trial needs a card is not stated.

What to know about Pencil’s prices

  • Since September 23, 2026, the help center calls generations credits and says their cost varies by model; the pricing page still says generations.
  • On Core and Growth, the monthly quota is a hard cap and unused generations do not carry over.
  • Each resized format costs one generation.
  • Pro is priced on request, with no cap on generations, users, brands or markets.
  • Fees are non-refundable under the terms, including after moving to a paid plan at the end of the trial.

Which is cheaper, AdCreative.ai or Pencil?

Pencil has the lower entry price. On November 17, 2026, its Core plan cost $14 a month, or $11 a month billed yearly, for 50 generations and one workspace. AdCreative.ai’s Starter plan cost $39 a month for 20 credits, one brand and one user, or $20 a month billed yearly during a Black Friday promotion.

The next steps differ. Pencil’s Growth plan costs $55 a month, or $44 billed yearly, for 250 generations, and Pro is priced on request with no cap on generations, users, brands or markets. AdCreative.ai sells larger Starter tiers at $89, $139 and $189 a month for 50, 85 or 120 credits and two brands, then Professional from $249 a month for 300 credits and 10 brands, and Ultimate from $999 a month for 25 brands.

The promotion matters when you compare. AdCreative.ai offered 50% off quarterly and yearly plans plus double credits, and its page does not show what those prices will be once the offer ends. Pencil shows its yearly prices per month, without the yearly total.

Does AdCreative.ai or Pencil have a free trial?

AdCreative.ai offers a 7-day trial with 20 credits and a reminder before it ends; the page does not say whether a card is needed, and there is no free plan. Pencil has no free plan either: you get six free guided ads at sign-up, then a paid plan is needed for full access.

Refunds are limited on both sides. Pencil’s FAQ says there is no refund after moving to a paid plan at the end of the trial, and its terms make fees non-refundable. AdCreative.ai’s terms (art. 4.7) give no withdrawal right and allow a refund only if the platform was not used.

Which one scores creatives before launch?

Both say they do. AdCreative.ai’s Creative Scoring AI predicts how a creative will perform before launch, but it is not part of Starter: Professional unlocks it, along with video generation and custom templates. Pencil’s homepage presents predictive creative scores and real-time insights next to its AI agents for copy, images and video.

AdCreative.ai adds two analysis tools: Creative Insights, which flags ad fatigue and compares your creatives with your category on connected accounts, and Competitor Insights. It also offers a Compliance Checker for brand and ad policy rules.

Can AdCreative.ai and Pencil launch ads on Meta?

Pencil can: it launches and tracks ads on Meta, TikTok, YouTube, Google, DV360 and LinkedIn, and lists Campaign Manager 360 and two asset libraries, Bynder and Orange Logic, among its integrations. AdCreative.ai connects Meta, Google and LinkedIn ad accounts and sends creatives to them directly; Pinterest and Microsoft Ads appear on its Creative Insights page.

Each resize counts on Pencil: AI Auto Resize costs one generation per format, and since September 23, 2026 its help center calls generations credits whose cost varies by model. On AdCreative.ai, generating is not capped; a credit is used when you download a creative.

What else should you know about AdCreative.ai and Pencil?

Still unsure? Email us. A real person replies.

On November 17, 2026, Starter cost $39 a month for 20 credits, Professional $249 a month for 300 credits and Ultimate $999 a month, with Enterprise on quote. Quarterly and yearly prices were cut by 50% for Black Friday.

Where do these figures come from?

AdCreative.ai

Pencil

What else can you compare?

See all comparisons

Meta ads, made easy

Launch your next campaign in 2 minutes.

Meta Ads