Published by Adwize, which makes an AI agent for Meta ads. We are not affiliated with Atria or Pencil. Prices read on their official pages on November 17, 2026.
The short answer
Choose Atria if you want research and analysis next to creation, on Meta and TikTok: it pairs an ad library of 100M+ ads and competitor tracking with Ad Maker, which makes AI video ads from a script, and Raya, an agent that writes briefs and uploads ads to Meta in bulk. Its free plan includes 1,000 credits with no card, and Maker Starter costs $19 a month for 1,500 credits. Team plans with analytics start at $129 a month billed yearly, read during a Black Friday promotion of up to 41% off. Choose Pencil if you mostly need to generate ads at a low price: Core costs $14 a month, or $11 billed yearly, for 50 generations, and Pencil launches and tracks ads on Meta, TikTok, YouTube, Google, DV360 and LinkedIn. Its quotas are hard caps with no rollover, and it has no free plan. Every figure here was read on the official pages on November 17, 2026.
How do Atria and Pencil compare?
| Criterion | Atria | Pencil |
|---|---|---|
| Category | Ad library and creative analytics | AI ad creative |
| Entry price, billed monthly | $19/mo (Maker Starter, 1,500 credits, 1 seat) | $14/mo (Core, 50 generations) |
| Entry price, billed yearly | $19/mo, same price billed yearly | $11/mo billed yearly (Core) |
| Free plan or trial | Free plan with 1,000 credits, no card | Six free guided ads at sign-up; no free plan |
| Pricing model | Credits and plan; $20 per extra seat on team plans | Generations (now called credits) per month; Pro on quote |
| Key features |
|
|
| Integrations | Meta (ad accounts, bulk uploads), TikTok (ad accounts), Slack, Google Drive, MCP (Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor), REST API, Chrome extension | Meta (Facebook and Instagram Ads), TikTok Ads, LinkedIn Ads, Google Ads, YouTube, DV360, Campaign Manager 360, Bynder and Orange Logic (DAM) |
| Rating shown by the vendor |
| No G2 or Capterra rating shown on its site |
What to know about Atria’s prices
- A Black Friday and Cyber Monday promotion (up to 41% off) was running on November 17, 2026, so the discounts shown may be temporary.
- Team plans start at $129 a month billed yearly (Core); their monthly prices appear only as crossed-out amounts ($219 for Core).
- The free plan appears on the homepage, in the FAQ and in the terms, but not in the price cards.
- Maker plans have one seat and no analytics or Radar.
- Subscriptions and credits are non-refundable under the terms.
What to know about Pencil’s prices
- Since September 23, 2026, the help center calls generations credits and says their cost varies by model; the pricing page still says generations.
- On Core and Growth, the monthly quota is a hard cap and unused generations do not carry over.
- Each resized format costs one generation.
- Pro is priced on request, with no cap on generations, users, brands or markets.
- Fees are non-refundable under the terms, including after moving to a paid plan at the end of the trial.
Which is cheaper, Atria or Pencil?
Pencil has the lowest paid entry. On November 17, 2026, its Core plan cost $14 a month, or $11 a month billed yearly, for 50 generations and one workspace. Atria’s Maker Starter cost $19 a month, the same price monthly or yearly, for 1,500 credits and one seat, and Atria also has a free plan.
For teams, Pencil’s Growth costs $55 a month, or $44 billed yearly, for 250 generations with no cap on workspaces, and Pro is priced on request. Atria’s team plans start with Core at $129 a month billed yearly, for 4,000 credits and 5 seats; its monthly price appeared only crossed out, at $219.
Atria’s prices were read during a Black Friday and Cyber Monday promotion of up to 41% off, so its team discounts may be temporary. Pencil’s yearly billing saves 20%, with no promotion shown.
Do Atria and Pencil have a free plan?
Atria does: a free plan with 1,000 credits and no card, mentioned on its homepage, in its FAQ and in its terms, though not in the price cards. Pencil has none. It gives six free guided ads at sign-up; after that, full access needs a paid plan, from $14 a month.
Refunds are strict on both sides. Atria’s terms make subscriptions and credits non-refundable. Pencil’s FAQ says there is no refund once you move to a paid plan after the trial, and its terms make fees non-refundable.
Which one helps you research and analyze ads?
Atria does. Its ad library covers Meta and TikTok with 100M+ ads, updated weekly, and you can follow competitor brands: 3 on Maker Starter, 50 on Core and 200 on Business. On team plans, analytics, AI creative tags and Radar, an AI strategist that runs around the clock, review your own results.
Pencil focuses on making ads. Its homepage presents predictive creative scores and real-time insights next to its AI agents for copy, images and video. Foreplay.co appears among its integrations, in closed beta.
Which ad platforms do Atria and Pencil cover?
Pencil covers more channels. It launches and tracks ads on Meta, TikTok, YouTube, Google, DV360 and LinkedIn, and connects to Campaign Manager 360, Bynder and Orange Logic. Atria works with Meta and TikTok only; its FAQ suggests other tools for YouTube or LinkedIn, and its agent Raya uploads ads to Meta in bulk.
Both make video with AI. Atria’s Ad Maker turns a script, a brief or a winning ad into a video ad, paid in credits. Pencil orchestrates models from several providers, such as OpenAI, Google, Adobe and Runway, and each resized format costs one generation.
