Published by Adwize, which makes an AI agent for Meta ads. We are not affiliated with Pencil or Superads. Prices read on their official pages on November 17, 2026.
The short answer
Choose Pencil if you want ads generated, launched and tracked from one tool: its AI agents draw on models from OpenAI, Google, Adobe and Runway to write copy and make images and video, predictive scores rate creatives, and Pencil launches ads on Meta, TikTok, YouTube, Google Display, DV360 and LinkedIn. Core costs $14 a month, or $11 billed yearly, for 50 generations, and six free guided ads come at sign-up. Choose Superads if you already have ads and want to know which work: it tags each ad with AI and scores it from 0 to 100 on Hook, Hold, Click, Engagement and Conversion across Meta, TikTok, LinkedIn and Google Ads, but makes no creatives. Professional costs $150 a month, or $125 billed yearly, up to $100k of monthly ad spend, with a 14-day trial. Superads shows 4.7/5 on G2. Every figure here was read on the official pages on November 17, 2026.
How do Pencil and Superads compare?
| Criterion | Pencil | Superads |
|---|---|---|
| Category | AI ad creative | Ad library and creative analytics |
| Entry price, billed monthly | $14/mo (Core, 50 generations) | $150/mo (Professional, up to $100k monthly ad spend) |
| Entry price, billed yearly | $11/mo billed yearly (Core) | $125/mo, billed $1500 yearly (Professional) |
| Free plan or trial | Six free guided ads at sign-up; no free plan | 14-day trial, no card per its LLM info page |
| Pricing model | Generations (now called credits) per month; Pro on quote | Ad spend of the last 30 days, all connected accounts |
| Key features |
|
|
| Integrations | Meta (Facebook and Instagram Ads), TikTok Ads, LinkedIn Ads, Google Ads, YouTube, DV360, Campaign Manager 360, Bynder and Orange Logic (DAM) | Meta (Facebook, Instagram), TikTok, LinkedIn, Google Ads (including Performance Max), Slack, Email reports, GA4, CSV export |
| Rating shown by the vendor | No G2 or Capterra rating shown on its site |
|
What to know about Pencil’s prices
- Since September 23, 2026, the help center calls generations credits and says their cost varies by model; the pricing page still says generations.
- On Core and Growth, the monthly quota is a hard cap and unused generations do not carry over.
- Each resized format costs one generation.
- Pro is priced on request, with no cap on generations, users, brands or markets.
- Fees are non-refundable under the terms, including after moving to a paid plan at the end of the trial.
What to know about Superads’s prices
- This is a starting price: above $100k of monthly ad spend, it adds $100 a month per extra 100k, adjusted each month.
- The help center article of September 24, 2026 gives $120 a month billed yearly; the pricing page showed $125.
- The free plan is closed to new sign-ups, although the homepage still says you can get started for free.
- Enterprise (over $1M of monthly ad spend) is custom priced.
Which is cheaper, Pencil or Superads?
Pencil starts lower. On November 17, 2026, its Core plan cost $14 a month, or $11 billed yearly, for 50 generations, and Growth $55 a month, or $44 billed yearly, for 250. Superads’ Professional cost $150 a month, or $125 a month billed $1,500 yearly, up to $100k of monthly ad spend.
They meter different things. Pencil caps generations each month with no rollover, now called credits in its help center, and Pro is priced on request. Superads follows ad spend: it adds $100 a month per extra 100k and quotes Enterprise above $1M a month.
Superads’ own pages disagree: a help article of September 24, 2026 gave $120 billed yearly, against $125 on the pricing page. Pencil’s terms make fees non-refundable.
Can you try Pencil or Superads?
Superads offers a 14-day trial, with no card according to its LLM info page. It closed its free plan to new sign-ups, although its homepage still says you can get started for free. Pencil has no free plan either, but gives six free ads through a guided flow at sign-up.
After those six ads, Pencil needs a paid plan for full access, and its FAQ gives no refund after you move to one.
Which one makes the ads?
Pencil does. Its AI agents generate copy, images, video and ads with models from OpenAI, Google, Adobe and Runway, you can build your own agents and workflows, and AI Auto Resize adapts a creative to each format, at one generation per format.
Superads makes no visuals, copy or videos. Its Inspiration area tracks competitor ads and keeps an inspiration library, but its focus is the ads you already run.
Which one tells you what works?
Superads is built for it. It tags each ad by hook, format, visual style and creator, scores it from 0 to 100 on Hook, Hold, Click, Engagement and Conversion, answers questions with Superads AI and sends scheduled Workflows to Slack or email. It keeps 12 months of history, per its LLM info page.
Pencil rates creatives with predictive scores and tracks the ads it launches on Meta, TikTok, YouTube, Google Display, DV360 and LinkedIn. Superads covers Meta, TikTok, LinkedIn and Google Ads, including Performance Max, though its help center lists Meta, LinkedIn and TikTok in the spend it counts, without Google Ads.
